Cuban food ration system marks 50 years amid controversy

Cuban food ration system marks 50 years amid controversy
10:14am EDT
By Rosa Tania Valdes

HAVANA | Fri Jul 12, 2013 1:31pm EDT
(Reuters) - Cuba's food-rationing system marked 50 years on Friday amid
controversy, with President Raul Castro facing popular resistance to his
plans to end the benefit as he moves the country from broad subsidies of
goods and utilities to targeted welfare.

Castro quickly began market-oriented reforms in 2008 after he replaced
his ailing brother Fidel, who installed a communist government on the
island nation in the early 1960s. But the younger Castro has criticized
the rationing system as "paternalistic, irrational and unsustainable."

The country spends 25 billion pesos (around $1 billion) annually on
rationing, subsidizing 88 percent of the cost, according to a source
close to the government.

The law establishing the system, known as the "libreta," was passed in
1962, and hundreds of ration stores opened on July 12, 1963.

A lifesaver for some and obsolete for others, eliminating rations has
proved perhaps the most controversial policy Castro has proposed.

"For many, the ration is necessary because it guarantees each month a
little rice, a few eggs, some sugar and milk," said Ignacio Lima, who
manages a small, dark and dingy ration outlet in Havana. "It is not
enough, but it helps a bit and then you go find what you need on the
open market."

After he spoke with a reporter, four shoppers at the store quickly began
debating the merits of the system - a discussion much like the one that
has raged across the Caribbean island for decades.

Olga Raquel Vazquez, 49, said there had to be a better way to feed
people. "The time has come for the ration to disappear," she said.

But Verena Rodriguez, a 72-year-old pensioner at 250 pesos per month,
the equivalent of $10 dollars, insisted she couldn't live without her
"libreta".

"It has to stay because without the ration some of us will eat and
others won't," she said.

"Who has money can buy everything and who doesn't can't," Rodriguez
said, adding that with 10 pesos, or around $0.45, she could buy what was
coming to her on the ration this week.

A LACK OF CONFIDENCE

Cuba has become a more stratified society since the collapse of its
benefactor, the Soviet Union, in the early 1990s. Reforms, such as an
opening to international tourism and foreign investment, the loosening
of restrictions on small businesses and the welcoming of family
remittances, were introduced to manage the economic and social crisis
that followed.

As a result of the reforms, small businessmen, farmers, residents with
family abroad and others now enjoy an income many times that of state
workers and pensioners, yet everyone receives the ration and subsidized
utilities.

"Undoubtedly, the ration book and its removal spurred most of the
contributions of the participants in the debates, and it is only
natural," Castro said in a speech to a Communist Party Congress in 2011,
after sponsoring three public discussion on reforming the economy since
taking over from his brother.

"Generations of Cubans have spent their lives under this ration system
that, despite its harmful egalitarian quality, has for four decades
ensured every citizen access to basic food at highly subsidized derisory
prices," he said.

Despite communism having its roots in social equality, Castro openly
opposes egalitarianism as harmful, saying that people should get what
they deserve through individual effort.

The Congress, as part of a five-year plan to institute further
market-oriented reforms, voted to do away with the ration, promising it
would be replaced by support for poorer Cubans.

But the government, faced with a popular outcry, has instead opted to
chip away at the libreta in hopes of gradually weaning the public off it.

Soap, detergent and cigarettes were first removed, followed by potatoes,
chickpeas and sugar. This month, the government cut in half its monthly
offer of 10 eggs.

Bert Hoffmann, a Cuba expert at the German Institute of Global and Area
Studies in Hamburg, said the resistance to ending the ration revealed a
lack of confidence in the government.

"It's only natural that people hang on to the "libreta", nobody likes to
give up virtually cost-free provisions if he gets nothing in return," he
said.

"And this is where Raul's reforms have failed: Cubans don't trust that
the targeted welfare system that the government promises will be better,
reliable or work at all."

(Writing and additional reporting by Marc Frank; Editing by Philip Barbara)

Source: "Cuban food ration system marks 50 years amid controversy |
Reuters" -
http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/07/12/us-cuba-reform-ration-idUSBRE96B0NP20130712?feedType=RSS&feedName=worldNews